Details and options listed here for when, what and how to pre-order! Let the feasting begin!
Have a question? See the FAQ below or give us a ring!
While pie orders are not required, we do highly recommend them!Christmas Week hours
M-W 9 to 6
Friday 25th - closed
In general, pie pre-order pick up typically starts around 10:30am for the /T/W/Th before the holiday
For Christmas Eve pickup, pies must be pre-paid.
Stop in or call us at 845-374-5471 (market is open every day 9 to 6) ORTEXT
your order to (845) 670-4540 - with your name, pie type and pick up day
Note! Cream pies can only avail 23rd/24th.Last day for orders Sunday Dec 20th please! After that we'll have pies on the shelf on first-come, first-served basis!
Bakery Options:Scotty’s Country Kitchen
- pies made from scratch since 1987! ($18.75) - last day to order Sunday Dec 20
*note, no cream pies until Wednesday*
No Sugar Added Apple (only cider used, no sugar substitutes)
Pecan order recommended
Sweet Potato by order only
Chocolate Cream by order only
Banana Cream by order onlyFrozen cheesecakes from Amish country: plain & apple caramel & pumpkin - just thaw and serve!Gluten-Free Pies by Mad Batter (of Marlboro NY) (6"- 10.75 or 9" - 35.75 )
Order by Dec 18 for pickup Dec 23-24We will probably have some on shelf for purchase starting late Dec 22
($15.75 9"/$7.99 6") , tarts, crisps- TBA for Christmas!Pie FAQWhere do I pick up my pie?
We will have pre-ordered pies separate from the store's regular bakery shelves.... so please look for signs or ask when you come in. If you can't come in Let us know your last name and we'll look you up and pull your pies for you. When can I pick up my pie?
Typically after 10:30 am on the day you designated, but if you want to call to be sure we have your pie on hand, feel free. Cream pies tend to be ready after lunch time.Do I need to refrigerate my pie?
For fruit pies, you can leave at room temp. (And of course we recommend you warm up the pie before serving!)
Pumpkin and cream pies should be refrigerated.Do I have to order pies?
No, ordering is optional though recommended. Scotty's will be making and delivering pies on an ongoing basis ... so sometimes the shelves will be full...and sometimes they won't! Please note we can't
put aside pies for anyone (we must be very strict on this, sorry!)Can you put aside a pie for me?
No, sorry, we can't.
Usually we do this, but not holiday weeks, as it's very busy... so it's pre-order or first come, first served from the shelf.Can I change my pick-up day?
You can change your order up until the order deadline for that particular pie; afterward you can only pick up on a later day (e.g. a Monday order can be picked up Tuesday).Do I need to pre-pay my pie?
2020: we highly recommend orders be pre-paid in order to speed pickups and reduce wait times.
On the holiday itself we ask pies be pre-paid (so Easter Day, Thanksgiving Day, Xmas Eve day)Can I pay with a credit card?
Got a question? let us know!