Happy Thanksgiving!
You do the turkey & leave the pies to us

Details and options listed here for when, what and how to pre-order.
Have a question? Give us a ring!

While pie orders are not required, we do highly recommend them!
(Please note for orders to be picked up Thanksgiving day, please stop in or call to pre-pay those.)

Stop in or call us at 845-374-5471 (every day 9 to 6) or text your order (with your full name, kind of pies and how many & your pick up day) to ‪845-670-4540‬

Pie Options:

Soons-cooked pies ($15)
Order by Sunday Nov 17 (also available frozen so you can pop in the oven on your own time)
No Sugar Added Peach (no sugar added pies use xylitol)
No Sugar Added Blueberry
No Sugar Added Cherry
Peach Praline
Red Raspberry
Strawberry Rhubarb
Very Berry
Coconut Custard

Note: we also offer frozen cheesecakes: plain, apple caramel, or pumpkin. Just thaw and serve!

Scotty’s Country Kitchen - pies made from scratch! ($18.75)
Order by Nov 24 for pick up M/T/W/Thanksgiving (note: no cream pies for Monday pickup)
Apple Crumb
Peach Crumb
Peach-Blueberry Crumb
Cherry Crumb
Apple-Cherry Crumb
Blueberry Crumb
Apple-Blueberry Crumb
No Sugar Added Apple (only cider used, no sugar substitutes)

Scotty’s Specialty Holiday Pies ($20)
Sweet Potato
Chocolate Cream
Banana Cream

Mad Batter Gluten Free Pies ($26)
Order by Nov 22 for pick up Tuesday afternoon/W/Thanksgiving
Apple (regular double crust)
Peach & Blueberry

Thanksgiving Week Hours*
Monday / Tuesday / Wednesday 8am to 6:30pm
(*pie pre-order pick up typically starts around 10am)
Thanksgiving 9am to noon (these pie orders must be pre-paid)